Google og Facebook gør os dumme

facebook dumt

I had a fun debate last night with one of my daughter’s friends. She’s 17 years old and already a professed centrist/liberal. It’s cool – I admire that she’s passionate about politics already. When I asked her what shows she watched to hear what was going on in the world, she said that it was pretty much Oprah and Jon Stewart… with some Anderson Cooper mixed in. I asked if she watched Bill O’Reilly or Fox News and a look of utter disgust came across her face. She noted that she hated Fox and would never watch it.

Min debat med hende var enkel ... Hvordan blev hun udsat for den anden side af argumentet, hvis alt hvad hun gjorde var at se eller høre den ene side? Simply put, she wasn’t. I asked her a ton of questions about politics… whether we had more troops overseas or less, whether the rich got richer over the past few years, whether more or less people were in prison, whether more or less people were on welfare, whether home ownership was up or down, whether the Middle East now saw us as a friend or still an enemy… she was frustrated because she couldn’t answer any of the questions.

I joked that she was simply a lemming (didn’t go over too well). By not exposing herself to other people’s ideology and opinions, she was robbing herself of the ability to make up her own mind. I don’t expect her to watch Fox and believe everything they say… she should listen and verify the information and come to her own conclusion. It’s absolutely okay to be a centrist or a liberal… but she should know that it’s also okay to be a conservative or libertarian. We should all respect one another.

Disclosure: I watch Bill O’Reilly and Fox News. I also watch CNN and BBC. I read NYT, WSJ and The Daily (when it’s working). I also like the Colbert Report and Jon Stewart once in a while. In all honesty, I gave up on MSNBC. I just don’t view it as news anymore.

It’s easy to have that debate when we talk about our choices and what we watch… but what about when we don’t have choices? Google og Facebook røver os of this and dumbing down the search and social interactions we get on the web. There’s not much I agree on with Eli Pariser af MoveOn ... men dette er en samtale, der skal ske (klik igennem for videoen). Som min gode ven Blog Bloke siger, gør Facebook os dumme.

When Facebook and Google own much of the information that is feeding our brains, should they be filtering it to a point where it actually could dumb us down? The popularity contest that drives search results and Facebook wall entries is just that… a popularity contest. Isn’t that the lowest common denominator of providing information? Shouldn’t we be developing algorithms that discover new and popular sites that provide us with insight rather than side with us?

5 Kommentarer

  1. 1

    Jeg så for nylig (og elskede!) Den video af Eli Pariser - kunne ikke være mere enig i hans vurdering. Selvom personalisering i nogle tilfælde er fantastisk, begrænser det vores verdenssyn væsentligt. Det påhviler Facebook, Google og andre at give os synlighed og kontrol med, hvordan de skræddersyr vores resultater, så vi kan beslutte at se ting, der ikke kun er relevante, men vigtige, ubehagelige og forskellige fra vores egne interesser.

  2. 2

    Jeg så for nylig (og elskede!) Den video af Eli Pariser - kunne ikke være mere enig i hans vurdering. Selvom personalisering i nogle tilfælde er fantastisk, begrænser det vores verdenssyn væsentligt. Det påhviler Facebook, Google og andre at give os synlighed og kontrol med, hvordan de skræddersyr vores resultater, så vi kan beslutte at se ting, der ikke kun er relevante, men vigtige, ubehagelige og forskellige fra vores egne interesser.

  3. 3

    Socialiseringen af ​​søgningen vil være under nedgangen af ​​uafhængige og upartiske søgeresultater og dødsmarken for søgemaskiner generelt, hvis de ikke holder op med at danse til Facebook-juggernaut. At gøre SERPS til en popularitetskonkurrence er en STOR fejl .. en, som jeg ikke ved, om Google kan komme sig. Det har mistet troværdigheden fra mit perspektiv. Skammeligt.

  4. 4

    en måde at imødegå google / facebook synspunkt er at kurere andre kilder uden for søgning. vi bør ikke stole på algoritmer med en enkelt kilde (google / facebook) for at præsentere information for os; i stedet skal vi bruge vores egne evner til at identificere informationsressourcer. dette betyder ikke ikke at bruge teknologi, det betyder at dyrke en praksis med opdagelse, der bringer serendipitet og synkronicitet.

Hvad mener du?

Dette websted bruger Akismet til at reducere spam. Lær, hvordan dine kommentardata behandles.